tag:blogger.com,1999:blog-7924779246254031438.post5556985937293735127..comments2023-10-29T06:15:11.903-07:00Comments on We Sikhs not Hindus: We Sikhs, Not HindusAjmer Singh Randhawahttp://www.blogger.com/profile/15431923929004062872noreply@blogger.comBlogger16125tag:blogger.com,1999:blog-7924779246254031438.post-81534334352374958322012-06-28T22:20:02.726-07:002012-06-28T22:20:02.726-07:00pls sir let my comment or reply to be published be...pls sir let my comment or reply to be published because I believe in integrity of humans..Anonymoushttps://www.blogger.com/profile/00651853712640739067noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-7924779246254031438.post-11452952112598978082012-06-28T22:09:25.860-07:002012-06-28T22:09:25.860-07:00i dont believe we are still bounded in the knots o...i dont believe we are still bounded in the knots of religion..!!<br />i am a college student i dont know if i am that experienced as you..<br />but whenever someone asks me my about my mother land,, i just reply INDIA, not delhi, haryana or punjab..<br /><br />AND MY ONLY RELIGION IS HUMANITY..!<br /><br />though i am a brahmin boy., i know in old times there were some bad rules like SATI PRATHA and all that but according to time everything changes.. now you can see a widow getting married again..!!<br />not in hindu religion but in all religions..!!<br /><br />AND YOU KNOW WHO IS MY BEST FREIND..<br />"AMARJEET SINGH" and we share our lunch and secrets and enjoy our time with each other.. <br />we are best freinds..!! :D<br /><br />its very bad to have these types of thoughts in this world..<br /><br />WE ARE INDIANS.. soldiers at border dont protect only one community or cast,, they protect all of us..!!<br /><br />WE SHOULD BE PROUD TO BE BORN IN THIS COUNTRY AND MAKE THIS COUNTRY'S FUTURE BRIGHT, WITH BRIGHT THOUGHTS..!<br />(not whith these diffrentiating thoughts)<br /><br />I VISIT BANGLA SAHEB GURUDWARA ALLWAYS WITHIN A MONTH..<br />NOT BECAUSE OF MY FRIEND.. JUST BECAUSE I RESPECT EVERY RELIGION OF MY COUNTRY, AND I GOT TO SEE THE CULTURE OF MY COUNTRY..!!<br />I ALWAYS HAVE THAT PARSADA.. :)<br />I ALWAYS BOW TO THAT GRANTHA SAHIB..!<br /><br />SOMETIMES WE ALSO DO "SEVA" THERE BY CUTTING VEGETABLES FOR LUNGERS..! :)<br /><br />I LOVE EACH AND EVERY SINGLE PERSON OF MY COUNTRY, NO MATTER IF ITS SIKH, HINDU, MUSLIM, CHRISTIAN..!!<br /><br />THE MAIN THING ABOVE THIS RELIGION IS OUR MOTHER LAND..<br />WHICH GIVES US HOME, WATER AND SHELTER TO SURVIVE..!!<br /><br />ACCORDING TO MY PERSONAL EXPERIENCE SIKHS ARE VERY GRACEFULL, I RESPECT SIKHS FROM MY HEART..!! <br /><br />(hope i have'nt hurted any of your religion views)<br /><br />NO MATTER I AM A SIKH/MUSLIM/HINDU..!!<br />I DOESN'T REPRESNT ANY RELIGION..<br /><br />I JUST REPRESENT MY NATION..<br />MY MOTHER.. "BHARAT" :D<br /><br />LIVE HAPPILY AND LIVE TOGETHER..! JAI HIND..! :DAnonymoushttps://www.blogger.com/profile/00651853712640739067noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-7924779246254031438.post-21649242864660195002011-11-06T01:44:40.686-08:002011-11-06T01:44:40.686-08:00att ne sir ji jo tusi facts kadhe... slute uatt ne sir ji jo tusi facts kadhe... slute uAnonymousnoreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-7924779246254031438.post-19484148217424897552011-03-24T06:11:21.322-07:002011-03-24T06:11:21.322-07:00Mr Ajay Virdi; You just try to pose yourself a Sik...Mr Ajay Virdi; You just try to pose yourself a Sikh but you are not. There is not any Sikhi like Sanatani Sikhi other then some brahiminacal minded Sikhs and Udasis who had the control of Sikh gurudwaras in joint Punjab, placed some idols in Gurudwaras and started worshipping them whereas idolatory is forbidden is Sikhism. This is already explained in this blog.<br />Guru Naank Dev ji and other Sikh Gurus always condemned the brahminical rituals and the Vedas, you can see the details in blog post above. Guru Nanak was the first Guru who refused to wear the sacred thread Janeu, he cooked meat in Kurukshetra and condemned the Hindu ritual of watering to dead in Pitralok by offering water in the west. So you can not prove if he ever preached Vedas and practiced Hindu rituals.<br />The name of Allah is also mentioned in Sri Guru Granth Sahib ji but read the above post and see the meanings of names of Gods applied but whether the Hindu gods accepted or condemned, note it. Everything is already explained but you are a fool who want to misguide by your post. First read the post and then comment.<br />There has never been any Hindu king in India for the last 1000 years so how can you praise the valor of Hindu warriors? Since the capture and death of last Hindu king Prithvi Raj chauhan, could you kindly example any hindu king in India? It was only Guru gobind Singh who appered on dead nation to give a new spirit of life by creration of khalsa. You call yourself a Sikh but you are totally ignorant of his call to his followers. He did not make any such call to offer him one son from each family but he desired everyone to become khalsa. It was Madan Mohan Malviya who gave this call to offer the elder son to Sikhism.<br />You even can not describe the weapons in Khanda and their application so leave it, this is also described in my another blog. Please go and learn some Sikh history. I advice you to follow your own religion and do not try to be over smart here. I myself is a historian and there are more than 50 blogs are written by me which I manage too.<br />Please read this blog carefully twice, thrice or more to get some knowledge of Sikhism. WE SIKHS ARE NOT HINDUS---REMEMBER IT.Ajmer Singh Randhawahttps://www.blogger.com/profile/15431923929004062872noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-7924779246254031438.post-17502409133800983372011-03-22T05:04:51.779-07:002011-03-22T05:04:51.779-07:00I am a Sikh & proud of both of my ancient heri...I am a Sikh & proud of both of my ancient heritage - one is of my great Hindu ancestors & the second is of my Sanatan Sikh ancestry. Sir, You are mostly mislead & you seem highly ignorant of your own historical background - you are like a Tree without Roots - you do not know or do not want to accept the fact that Sanatan Sikhi is Sanatan Hindu Dharma - Ek Onkara, Nirguna, Niraakar, Nirbhay, Karma, Dharma, Sewa, to name a few are ALL Vedanta principles which our great Gurus who themselves were Hindus have drawn out of Vedic philosophy during a time when our country was facing great tyranny under the Muslm invaders. The Bhakti period of this time saw great Sants like Kabir, Guru NanakDevji etc come out to translate the Veda Puranas to uplift the morale of the Hindus of Punjab. In fact Sanatan Sikhi is more closer to Hindu Dharma than any other offshoot of Hinduism like Buddhism & Jainism. Shri Raam is mentioned over 3000 times in Guru Granth Sahibji & Shri Hari is mentioned over 8500 times - Guru NanakDevji himself mentions this great Hindu name for Paramatma as Hari over 670 times. Hindus have a great couragious historical heritage. We have adapted the Khanda, Omkara etc from our great Hindu ancestry. Guru Gobind Rai ji himself asked all Hindus of Punjab to give him their elder son so that he could organise a highly skilled kshatriya army known as Khalsa. They adopted all the Sanatan Dharmic principles of warfare & Hindu martial arts- Khanda is an ancient Hindu weapon representing Shiva & Shakti.Look up Ardhanarishwar sculptures from the Chola Period & you will see where we get the Khanda from. You narrowminded egoistic 'Sikhs' are bringing the rest of our proud heritage down because I doubt if the Hindus care less whether we are part of them or not since you are far more poorer for living in denial & denying both your Hindu ancestry as well as Sanatan Sikh ancestry & making Sikhism a separate identity/religion of Turbaned & Bearded peoples. <br />You also forget most of the warriors in the Khalsa were Hindus - Banda Bahadur was a Brahmin known as Lakshman Dev Bharadwaj - neo Sikhs have white washed this fact & reduced the unsung hero to strange name - Lacchman Das & calling him a Rajput. Had he been a Rajput he would have the name Singh at birth. It is ridiculous they have painted such a wrong picture of Sikh history by conveniently leaving out the Chibber Brahmins who also fought to establish the Sikh Kingdom alongside with Lakshman Dev bharawaj - aka Banda Singh Bahadurji.<br />Sanatan Sikhi is more than just an affair of Turbaned & Bearded people from Punjab.<br />Plse grow up & learn YOUR great history.<br />Vaheguruji Ka Khalsa<br />Vahegurji Ki Fateh<br /><br />Ajay Singh VirdiAnonymousnoreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-7924779246254031438.post-43398532270138920202010-11-12T07:01:04.787-08:002010-11-12T07:01:04.787-08:00you have not written any thing on Omkar( ek Omkar)...you have not written any thing on Omkar( ek Omkar) which is the base of sikh. its better if you learn basic facts of sikh panth. your all sentances are incomplete.Acharya Kaushikhttps://www.blogger.com/profile/05093412748448023807noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-7924779246254031438.post-69456393103148627132010-06-14T03:28:08.239-07:002010-06-14T03:28:08.239-07:00I somewhat agree with your article but personally ...I somewhat agree with your article but personally i think there is some hatred thats evident here. <br />I feel a person should see another person as a fellow human being and not as a hindu/sikh/christian and at the same time respect one's religion as well other's.<br />A soldier who stands in the freezing cold at the border protects us all irrespective of our castes. He maybe a hindu/sikh/muslim/christian but happily devotes a better part of his life protecting us ALL.<br />The main message in any religion is LOVE YOUR FELLOW HUMAN BEINGS.Anonymousnoreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-7924779246254031438.post-86390744168622671432010-05-04T04:56:39.359-07:002010-05-04T04:56:39.359-07:00Ajmer Singh ji, I learned a lot from your work. Th...Ajmer Singh ji, I learned a lot from your work. Thank you for investing so much time into this to educate people like me.<br /><br />Rajan, everyone knows it and appreciates the fact that hindus families saved many innocent lives in 84 etc. but the thing is, were those hindus saving innocents the same hindus who were harming them? obviously, not! So, of course, the fight is against the culprits not the entire community or group. If we want every community to be as one in a country, unfairness towards the people of a particular faith or group should at least be condemned openly by the large population; but, we rarely see this happening. so how can we hope for unity when no attempts are made to obtain it.<br /><br />Unity of a country is not dependent on kind or number of religions it has rather it is on how the citizens of that nation are treated… You can expect unity where everyone is treated equally (after the horrific past acts have been rectified). <br /><br />many today’s indians say "Before we are hindu, musilum, sikh, etc., we are indians" but I say "Before we are indians, we are human!"Anonymousnoreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-7924779246254031438.post-33986778032515020462010-05-02T10:14:26.254-07:002010-05-02T10:14:26.254-07:00Dear Randhawa Jee,
Please also add other Kuritian...Dear Randhawa Jee,<br /><br />Please also add other Kuritian of Brahmin vaad such as -<br /><br />Widow suppression / SATI / cutting of women hair after husband death (Rejected by Sikh Gurus) / Torture of widows after death / Not allowing widow to eat / worship / take water from same well.<br />Dowry (Rejected by Sikh Gurus)<br />Kundli system / Janam Patri (Rejected by Sikhs and Sikh Gurus)<br />Matching of Janam Kundlis at marriage / concept of Manglik etc. (Rejected by Sikh Gurus)<br />Propaganda to common people to Worship planets and scare of planets such as Jupiter / Saturn (Rejected by Sikh Gurus) by Brahmins to earn wealthJasmeethttps://www.blogger.com/profile/08029680799049656829noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-7924779246254031438.post-46011058962154015702010-05-02T07:16:25.976-07:002010-05-02T07:16:25.976-07:00Dear Randhawa Jee,
Your article is an eye-opener,...Dear Randhawa Jee,<br /><br />Your article is an eye-opener, I think there are a lot of traitors in our own religion who are portraying our religion in bad light and submerging our religion. We don't have to let it happen. <br /><br />Jasmeet SinghJasmeethttps://www.blogger.com/profile/08029680799049656829noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-7924779246254031438.post-77298532657674152322010-03-02T21:05:44.364-08:002010-03-02T21:05:44.364-08:00Our Chinese friend says....With actions to support...Our Chinese friend says....With actions to support you ~ ~ ~ is not a message No!<br />Thank you for the comment Mr. LuckAjmer Singh Randhawahttps://www.blogger.com/profile/15431923929004062872noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-7924779246254031438.post-17339089943062912362009-06-25T19:09:11.843-07:002009-06-25T19:09:11.843-07:00I ajmer Singh Randhawa do appreciate the comment o...I ajmer Singh Randhawa do appreciate the comment of Tyagiji, whereas Mr. Rajan saye that Sikhs were saved by RSS that is not true but Neither all Sikhs nor Hindus are against each other, no doubt many were saved by Hindus. Thanks to all of them.<br />Religiously we are separate but in the hour of need we shall be united, i hope and wish.Ajmer Singh Randhawahttps://www.blogger.com/profile/15431923929004062872noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-7924779246254031438.post-47313507250148252992009-06-12T13:55:04.365-07:002009-06-12T13:55:04.365-07:00see, i born in a tyagi brahmin warrior class(mohiy...see, i born in a tyagi brahmin warrior class(mohiyals as they known in punjab), i am a s/w engineer. i know my lineage but i neither am fighting for a king nor am i doing any priestly work. When ppl ask me who am i, i say u may please decide, i need no tags of hindu, muslim etc. when it comes to if sikhs r part of hindus , i tell them- they are what they decide. why force? if sikhs think they r separate than hindus, respect it. Sikhs are known for respecting all, so if they are given respect, respect is all one will get. so why not. not being hindu dsnt mean one is not indian or will work against india. this country belongs to all.<br /><br />Peace and Jai Guru Dev,Akal PurkhTyaginoreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-7924779246254031438.post-72836112834398728282009-06-10T06:24:58.015-07:002009-06-10T06:24:58.015-07:00we r not hindus they have us hindus in constitutio...we r not hindus they have us hindus in constitution but who r they to decide that.<br />our culture,rituals,history every thing is different .......<br /> we r SIKH ..........<br />and we r slaves in indiaUnknownhttps://www.blogger.com/profile/17353456485013297450noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-7924779246254031438.post-64577878832287605332009-05-30T02:37:47.175-07:002009-05-30T02:37:47.175-07:00It all looks good, there are several sects in Hind...It all looks good, there are several sects in Hindus donot practice Idol puja. The message is important & togetherness.<br />Lets clear the facts in 1984 RSS saved sikhs in Delhi & in 1962 RSS helped civilians rescuded .<br /><br />In 1947 RSS & Guridwaras combine helped all people from Muslims.<br /><br />Yes Sikhs may be differed, but do we want to be differet when comes the good work. <br />We are all oneRajannoreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-7924779246254031438.post-41200439173607005222008-12-19T22:51:00.000-08:002008-12-19T22:51:00.000-08:00When India was partitioned, one million people die...When India was partitioned, one million people died,crores are displaced and property worth billions perished, Congress leader Pundit Jawaharlal Nehrue was flirting with the wife of Mounbetton....Edwina Mounbetton during that difficult time phase. When Sikhs were thinking of next day bread for their family, Nehruvians and leftists(USSR men)were trying to capture kye posts in the corridors of beurocracy.While writting history, Guru Arjan Dev ji's martyredom is not important. If TUZKE- JAHANGIRI is mentioned, they will not get muslim votes.These bogies raised the question of secularism. Word 'Secularism' is based on the voting pattern of a social group, so it is a lie. Shri Guru Granth Sahib gives us a terminology "SANJHIWALTA", which is based on the very existence of AKAL-PURAKH, so it is true.Nehruvians are creating the lobby of anti hinduism and branding Guru Tegh Bahadur ji as LOOTERA in history books of C.B.S.E. and N.C.E.R.T. Only Nehruvians has LADDOO in their both hands.<BR/> JAGJIVAN JOT SINGH ANANDjagjivan jot singh anandhttps://www.blogger.com/profile/18339351825063316489noreply@blogger.com